CALGARY — For the second consecutive season, the Montreal Alouettes will spend the off-season wondering what could have been after coming up short in another Grey Cup.
In front of 32,419 fans at McMahon Stadium on Sunday night, the Alouettes had plenty of chances to win the franchise's ninth championship. Instead, they were unable to make the plays when it mattered, falling 37-30 to the Edmonton Elks, who celebrated their first title since 2015.
The Alouettes showed plenty of fight throughout the evening, responding to Edmonton's scoring drives and finding ways to stay within striking distance.
Instead, Cody Fajardo — the quarterback Montreal moved on from after he delivered a championship in 2023 — returned to haunt his former club, finding ways to make plays against the Alouettes in critical situations.
The tone was set on the opening kickoff, when Montrell Washington went down the sidelines for a 78-yard return, setting up a pass-interference flag and a one-yard Fajardo sneak for an early 7-0 hole.
To their credit, the Alouettes responded right away with quarterback Davis Alexander showing great poise by converting on three straight second-down situations before hitting Tyson Philpot, who bounced off tacklers for a 26-yard score.
Montreal also took advantage of some undisciplined moments from Edmonton, including a roughing-the-passer penalty against Edmonton’s Malik Carney, which gifted Montreal an 18-yard field goal and a 10-7 edge.
Yet whenever Montreal cracked the door open, Edmonton slammed it shut.
The Elks used their versatility on offence, finding ways to turn in positive plays and keep Montreal's defence on the field.
Even with the Alouettes forcing the Elks to make mistakes, with Kabion Ento intercepting a pass from Fajardo and Isaac Adeyemi-Berglund recovering a fumble by Brendan O’Leary-Orange in the fourth quarter, they were unable to take control of the game.
Edmonton's defence was increasingly successful at taking away the explosive plays that had made the Alouettes' offence so dangerous throughout the season.
The Elks played with a deeper coverage shell, keeping Montreal's receivers in front of them and forcing Alexander to work underneath. Stevie Scott III delivered an impressive performance on the ground, finishing with 133 rushing yards, but the Alouettes couldn't consistently translate that production into the passing plays they needed.
"I didn't play well enough in the second half," Alexander admitted, calling his performance disappointing and embarrassing. "I feel like I cost us the game for sure. I have to be better in a big game, especially in the second half when the team's relying on me."
To the Elks' credit, they didn't need flashy plays to get the win. Instead, they relied on what the Alouettes' defence gave them and weren't overly aggressive.
When asked what Maas thinks his team needed to do better, the Alouettes coach didn't mince words.
"We didn't make enough plays, to be blunt," he said, pointing to a missed throw to a wide-open receiver on second-and-inches and a red-zone stall that left points on the turf.
Named the game's Most Outstanding Canadian, Philpot — playing in front of family and friends at the familiar McMahon Stadium, where he played for the Calgary Dinos — had little appetite for silver linings after failing to haul in a couple of deep shots that could have flipped the script.
"The game was there for us to win," Philpot said. "We just didn't make enough plays."
One play that also appeared to hurt the Alouettes in more ways than one was when Carney drove Alexander to the turf after getting free on a pass rush.
Head coach Jason Maas threw the challenge flag, convinced the defensive lineman had landed with his full body weight on the quarterback.
The command centre disagreed, and the ruling stood.
“In the rulings, it always states if someone lands with their full body force on a quarterback, it's going to get called. That's what I saw, and that's why I challenged it," Maas explained. "In the middle of a Grey Cup game, I decided to challenge what I saw as a player, a defensive player, lift our quarterback up, land full body weight on him.
“Now, the referees didn't see it on the field, so I may be wrong. And then I challenge it and the head referee in Toronto didn't see it that way. I will go to my grave saying that should have been a foul, but I'll live with the consequence of it, which it wasn't. And I'll argue my ass off come January that it was.”
Alexander showed discomfort in his shoulder after the play, but insisted that it didn't impact his ability to make plays.
"I'm not going to make any excuse for that," Alexander said. "There were a couple of times I threw the ball deep still, so there's no excuse."
The Alouettes quarterback, who is now 0-2 in his attempt to bring home a Grey Cup, didn't try to deflect blame.
He also knows that it's another moment he'll reflect on and think about how he can do better going forward.
Fajardo, who was with Alexander in 2024, knows what it's like to miss out in big moments given how long it took him to finally get his first win as a starter.
The Elks quarterback said he shared a brief moment with Alexander after the game.
"I told him after the game, I said his dad is so damn proud of him, and I was so proud of him," Fajardo said.
Alexander knows getting back to the Grey Cup is never guaranteed, but the motivation to return will be there after another painful defeat.
"I'm 0-2 in the Grey Cup, and I'll do whatever it takes to get her back," Alexander vowed.
For Maas, the disappointment was about a team that had done so much to put itself in position, only to come up short when it mattered most.
“It sucks. It was a special season,” Maas said. “It just doesn't finish.”
Now the team has to wait another six months to get back on the field and earn another trip to the final.


1:08


